VBA Format Conditions For Next Loop

Problem: Placing a With/End With for FormatConditions in a For/Next loop isn't applying the conditional formatting.

Information:
- I have a stats section that has months as the column headers with totals at the end (used as a VLOOKUP table)
- Each column needs the conditional formatting separately
- The columns are static, but the rows are variable
- Taking it out of the loop and coding each loop individually works perfectly

The problem code:

finalRowTable = Cells(Rows.Count, 12).End(xlUp).Row
For i = 13 To 38
With Range(i & "11:" & i & finalRowTable)
.FormatConditions.Delete
.FormatConditions.AddTop10
.FormatConditions(1).TopBottom = xlTop10Top
.FormatConditions(1).Rank = 1
.FormatConditions(1).Percent = False
.FormatConditions(1).Interior.Color = 5296274
End With
Next i

I checked after running it and it doesn't show up in the Manage Rules Conditional Formatting

Code that works without loop:
Code:
With Range("N11:N" & finalRowTable)
.FormatConditions.Delete
.FormatConditions.AddTop10
.FormatConditions(1).TopBottom = xlTop10Top
.FormatConditions(1).Rank = 1
.FormatConditions(1).Percent = False
.FormatConditions(1).Interior.Color = 5296274
End With

I've been playing with excel VBA for a few months now, so it's probably something simple.