Excel 2010 :: After Argument In Find Not Working

In an Excel Pro Plus 2010 workbook on a Windows 7 PC, trying to use the "After" argument in a VBA .Find function and it's not working as expected.

I've got the following data in column D:

Row1: Title
Row2: Row2Data
Row3: Row3Data

And using this simple procedure:

Sub FindTest()
If Range("D:D").Find("Title", After:=Range("D1")) Is Nothing Then
Debug.Print "Not Found"
Else
Debug.Print Range("D:D").Find("Title", After:=Range("D1")).Row
End If
End Sub

My expecation is that "Not Found"will be returned, but instead I'm getting the row # (1).

If I change the value in D1 the procudure returns "Not Found", as expected.
If I change the find argument to look for "Row2Data" it returns 2.

I also tried changing the "After" argument to "D2" ... same result.

Finally, I tried using this format: "Range("D:D").Find("Title", [D2])" and got the same result.